Fasten New Treads with Screws
From How to Stop a Stair Tread from Creaking and Shifting · Step 2 of 5 · Video by The Honest Carpenter

Showing 5:17–6:11 of the source video. Watch the full video with every moment.
What happens in this clip
Position the new tread onto the adhesive-coated stringers, ensuring an approximately 1/8-inch gap between the new tread and the riser board behind it. For fastening, always use screws (2.5-inch exterior grade screws are recommended) as they provide a much tighter and more durable hold than nails. Pre-drill pilot holes with an 1/8-inch drill bit, aligning them with the center of each stringer. This prevents the wood from splitting when the screws are driven. Use an impact driver to drive the screws in, countersinking the heads slightly below the surface of the tread. For the front edge of the tread, where the stringer's wood grain might be sketchy or prone to splitting, carefully drive a screw into the riser board below instead of the stringer for a more secure connection.
Goal: Place the new treads onto the adhesive-coated stringers and secure them with exterior-grade screws, pre-drilling pilot holes to prevent splitting.
What's used
Tools
- 1/8-inch Drill Bit
- Drill
- Impact Driver
Materials
- 2.5-inch Exterior Grade Screws Generic Tan Exterior
About the full video
This video provides detailed instructions on how to replace individual worn wood stair treads on a deck using direct fastening. It emphasizes careful removal of old treads to avoid damaging the underlying stringers, precise measurement and cutting of new lumber, and securing new treads with a combination of structural adhesive and screws for enhanced durability. Special attention is given to preventing common failure points like tread overhang and splitting, including an optional solution for steps with excessive overhang.
Step 2 of 5: Secure Loose Tread Edges
If the edges of the stair tread are loose, drive screws or finish nails through the tread and into the underlying stringer or supporting joist. For a cleaner finish, use finish nails and set them slightly below the surface, or pre-drill pilot holes and use wood screws, countersinking them so the heads are flush or slightly below the wood surface. If driving screws from the top, consider filling the holes with wood putty later for a seamless look.
Every video in How to Stop a Stair Tread from Creaking and Shifting
Step 1: Inspect the Stair Tread
- 2:21–3:48 Diagnose Creaking Causes
Step 2: Secure Loose Tread Edges
- 6:29–7:31 Drive Screws to Secure Tread to Riser
- 6:13–6:27 Secure Front Treads with Screws
- 5:17–6:11 Fasten New Treads with Screws (this video)
Step 3: Address Gaps with Shims and Adhesive
- 6:22–6:49 Apply 5-Minute Wood Adhesive
- 6:40–7:13 Apply Wood Glue (Back Risers)
- 2:05–4:08 Reinforce Risers and Treads with Adhesive and Timber
Step 4: Reinforce with Stair Tread Repair Brackets
- 4:51–8:26 Fix with Heavy-Duty Stair Angle Brackets (Method 2)
- 0:15–2:32 Fix with A35 Brackets (Method 1)
- 0:33–0:58 Utilize Prefabricated Metal Brackets
Step 5: Fill Screw Holes and Finish
- 0:22–0:30 Fill Screw Holes with Wood Putty
- 1:40–2:44 Prepare Surface by Filling Holes
- 4:25–4:47 Fill Gaps and Nail Holes
How to Stop a Stair Tread from Creaking and Shifting
Outline for a DIY project to fix a creaking and shifting stair tread.
Read the full guide Browse all guides
Planning this project? Shop Oak Valley Designs.

